Kyle started coaching at Divine Savior Holy Angels in 1991 and held that role for 16 seasons. He coached Waukesha North Co-op for 17 years before returning to DSHA in 2024.
Kyle also started as the Head Coach for Marquette University High School, where he graduated from in 1987. Swimmers have won state titles and sectional championships, been High School All-Americans, and earned college swimming scholarships during his coaching career.
Just as important as the accomplishments in the water, there were 51 academic all-Americans as well. Kyle was the President of the Wisconsin Interscholastic Swim Coaches Association for 10 years and in June of 2025 will become the National Interscholastic Swimming Coaches Association President. He has also advanced to the American Swim Coaches Association Level 4 certification.